In the Money vs. Out of the Money Options

In the Money vs. Out of the Money – ITM, ATM and OTM options explained

In the money, at the money and out of the money describe where an option’s strike price sits compared to the stock price. These terms, often shortened to ITM, ATM and OTM, tell you whether an option has any real value right now, and they shape how it behaves as the stock moves.

What Does In the Money Mean?

  • In the money call: the stock price is above the strike price.
  • In the money put: the stock price is below the strike price.

An in the money option has intrinsic value, meaning it would be worth something if you exercised it right now. A 90 strike call on a $100 stock is $10 in the money.

What Does Out of the Money Mean?

  • Out of the money call: the stock price is below the strike price.
  • Out of the money put: the stock price is above the strike price.

An out of the money option has no intrinsic value. Its whole price is extrinsic value, made up of time value and implied volatility. If it’s still out of the money at expiration, it expires worthless.

At the Money vs. In the Money

An at the money option has a strike price at or very close to the stock price. It has little or no intrinsic value, but it usually carries the most extrinsic value of any strike. ATM options also have a delta near 0.50, so they move about half as much as the stock. Deep in the money options have a delta closer to 1.00 and move almost dollar for dollar with the stock. You can learn more in understanding option delta.

In the Money and Out of the Money Example

Say XYZ trades at $100. Here’s how three calls with the same expiration might be priced:

  • 90 call, in the money: $11.50. That’s $10 of intrinsic value plus $1.50 of extrinsic value.
  • 100 call, at the money: $4.00, all extrinsic value.
  • 110 call, out of the money: $1.00, all extrinsic value.

For puts, it flips. The 110 put would be $10 in the money, and the 90 put would be out of the money.

ITM VS OTM Options at a glanceIN THE MONEYHas valueAT THE MONEYAt strikeOUT OF MONEYTime onlyExample stock price: $100Where each strike sits at $100CALLSPUTSOTM$0ITM$10$110OTM$0ITM$5$105ATM$0ATM$0$100ITM$5OTM$0$95ITM$10OTM$0$90STRIKECalls gain value as the stock rises above the strike.Puts gain value as it falls below the strike.Dollar amounts show intrinsic value. Time value comes on top.

Are All In the Money Options Profitable?

No, and this trips up a lot of new traders. In the money only means the option has intrinsic value. Whether you’re making money depends on what you paid.

Say you buy the 100 call for $5 and the stock rises to $103. Your call is $3 in the money, but at expiration it’s worth only $3, so you’ve lost $2 a share. You need the stock above $105, your breakeven, to profit at expiration.

Do Out of the Money Options Have Extrinsic Value?

Yes. In fact, extrinsic value is all they have. That value comes from time left until expiration and implied volatility. As expiration gets closer, the extrinsic value melts away through time decay, which is why out of the money options lose value fast if the stock doesn’t move.

Buying Options In the Money vs. Out of the Money

  • Buying in the money: costs more, but has a higher chance of finishing in the money and moves more like the stock. Less of what you pay is time value that can decay away.
  • Buying out of the money: costs less and offers bigger percentage gains if the stock makes a big move, but it has a lower chance of paying off.

Many traders buy in the money options when they want stock-like exposure with less money tied up, and out of the money options when they’re betting on a big, fast move.

In the Money vs. Out of the Money FAQ

What happens to an in the money option at expiration?

Options that finish $0.01 or more in the money are usually exercised automatically. If you don’t want to buy or sell the shares, close the position before expiration.

Can an out of the money option become profitable?

Yes. If the stock moves past the strike, or the option gains value from a jump in implied volatility, you can sell it for more than you paid before expiration.

Which is better to sell, in the money or out of the money?

Most option sellers sell out of the money options, because they have a higher chance of expiring worthless and letting the seller keep the premium.

What does deep in the money mean?

There’s no official cutoff, but traders usually call an option deep in the money when the stock is well past the strike, often by 10% or more, and its delta is above about 0.80. These options trade almost like the stock itself and carry very little time value.

Conclusion

In the money options have intrinsic value, out of the money options are pure time value, and at the money options sit right on the line. Knowing the difference helps you pick strikes that match your goal, your budget and how much risk you’re willing to take.

Want to learn how to pick the right strike for every trade? Check out our beginner’s options trading course.


Chris Douthit
Chris Douthit

Chris Douthit, MBA, CSPO, is a former professional trader for Goldman Sachs and the founder of OptionStrategiesInsider.com. His work, market predictions, and options strategies approach has been featured on NASDAQ, Seeking Alpha, Marketplace, and Hackernoon.