Butterfly Spread with Puts Option Strategy

Butterfly Spread with Puts option strategy banner with payoff chart

A butterfly spread with puts is a defined-risk options strategy that profits when a stock finishes near a specific price at expiration. You buy one put at a higher strike, sell two puts at a middle strike and buy one put at a lower strike, all with the same expiration. It’s one of the cheapest ways to bet on a stock staying put, or drifting to a target.

How the Put Butterfly Spread Works

  • Buy 1 put at strike C, the highest strike
  • Sell 2 puts at strike B, the middle strike
  • Buy 1 put at strike A, the lowest strike

The strikes are evenly spaced, and you pay a small debit to open the trade. That debit is your max loss.

Put Butterfly Diagram

PUT BUTTERFLYPayoff ata glanceMAX RISK$300BREAKEVENS$93 / $107MAX PROFIT$700Buy $110 put, sell 2 $100,buy $90 putProfit and loss at expirationA $90B $100C $110$700$0-$300Max profit $700Max loss $300XYZ PRICE AT EXPIRATIONBreakevenStrikeoptionstrategiesinsider.com

Like the call version, the payoff looks like a tent that peaks at strike B. Below strike A or above strike C, you lose the debit.

Max Profit, Max Loss and Breakeven

  • Max profit: strike C minus strike B, minus the debit. You get it if the stock closes at strike B.
  • Max loss: the debit paid.
  • Upper breakeven: strike C minus the debit.
  • Lower breakeven: strike A plus the debit.

Put Butterfly Example

XYZ trades at $100. You buy the 105 put for $6.40, sell two 100 puts for $3.40 each and buy the 95 put for $1.40. Your net debit is $1.00, or $100, and your breakevens are $96 and $104. At expiration:

  • XYZ at $100: the 105 put is worth $5 and the rest expire worthless. You make $4 a share, or $400.
  • XYZ at $98: the 105 put is worth $7 and the two 100 puts cost you $4, so the spread is worth $3. You make $2 a share, or $200.
  • XYZ below $95 or above $105: you lose the $100 debit.

Put Butterfly vs. Call Butterfly

With the same strikes and expiration, a put butterfly and a call butterfly have nearly identical payoffs and prices. Traders pick one or the other based on which options have tighter bid-ask spreads, or to avoid early assignment on in-the-money options. If you center a put butterfly below the current price, it becomes a bearish trade, similar to a Christmas tree spread with puts.

Butterfly Option Settlement

At expiration, in-the-money options are exercised automatically. If the stock closes between your strikes, you could end up with a stock position from the legs that finished in the money, so most traders close butterflies before expiration. Cash-settled index options like SPX avoid this, since they settle in cash instead of shares.

When to Use a Butterfly Spread in Options

  • You expect the stock to land near a specific price by expiration.
  • You want a big potential payoff for a small, fixed risk.
  • Implied volatility is high and you expect it to drop.

Tips for Trading the Put Butterfly

  • Center it where you expect the stock to land. The middle strike is your target, so put it at the price you think the stock will finish.
  • Use liquid options. Four contracts across three strikes means bid-ask spreads matter. Start at the midpoint and work your order.
  • Be patient, then take profits. Butterflies gain most of their value in the final week or two. Many traders close once they’ve doubled their debit instead of waiting for max profit.
  • Keep your size small. The risk is limited, but max profit is rare, so spread your bets across several trades.

Common Put Butterfly Mistakes

  • Holding into expiration near a short strike. If the stock finishes right around the middle strike, you can be partly assigned. Closing a day or two early avoids surprises.
  • Ignoring trading costs. A butterfly has three strikes and four contracts, so wide bid-ask spreads can take a big bite out of the profit.
  • Centering it in the wrong spot. The trade only pays well near the middle strike, so set it where you realistically expect the stock to finish.

Put Butterfly FAQ

What is a butterfly option strategy?

It’s a three-strike trade that buys one option, sells two at the middle strike and buys one more, all the same type and expiration. It profits most if the stock finishes at the middle strike.

Can I lose more than the debit?

Not if you close before expiration or the stock settles outside your strikes. The risk to watch is ending up with shares if you hold through expiration with the stock between the strikes.

How far out should I trade a butterfly?

Many traders use 2 to 6 weeks. Butterflies gain value fastest near expiration if the stock is close to the middle strike.

Conclusion

The put butterfly is a low-cost, defined-risk way to target a price. It works just like the call version, so pick whichever gives you better fills, and plan to close before expiration.

To learn how to trade butterflies and other spreads, check out our beginner options trading course.


Chris Douthit
Chris Douthit

Chris Douthit, MBA, CSPO, is a former professional trader for Goldman Sachs and the founder of OptionStrategiesInsider.com. His work, market predictions, and options strategies approach has been featured on NASDAQ, Seeking Alpha, Marketplace, and Hackernoon.